Welcome to Sugar²Squared
Welcome to Sugar²Squared, a home bakery in Whitby specializing in homemade butter tarts and sweet treats, baked from scratch in small batches. We use real ingredients and we don’t hold back on flavour or filling, because butter tarts aren’t supposed to be subtle. We bake with extra ingredients, keep them affordable, and make desserts that actually feel worth it. Orders are available for pickup by arrangement.
"Stressed" is just "desserts" spelled backwards
Relax and take a break today with a homemade sweet treat from us!
Celebrate Christmas with Sugar²Squared! 🎄
The Christmas season is here, and we're busy preparing our handcrafted butter tarts, delicious fudge, toffee bars, and exciting new holiday creations!
We're looking forward to celebrating the season with you at these special events:
- November 7 — Burlington Centre Christmas Market
- November & December — Hope's Christmas Tree Farm, Enniskillen
- December 13 — Picks & Giggles Christmas Market, Oshawa
A Note About Online Ordering
While we focus on preparing for our Christmas events, online ordering will be temporarily paused.
Don't worry, we haven't forgotten about our online customers! Depending on remaining inventory, we may offer a limited selection of Christmas treats for online ordering later in December.
Watch our website and social media for updates!
Thank you for your continued support, and we hope to see you this holiday season!
From our Sugar²Squared kitchen to your home, wishing you a sweet and wonderful Christmas! 🎄
Tarts
Fudge
Toffee Bars
Extra Products
Please Click a Picture to make your own individualized pack
Featured product
Butter Tart - Gingerbread²
Back for a limited time this holiday season our gingerbread butter tart is back. Made with gingerbread in the crust and ginger cookie crumble in the filling. Topped with white chocolate.
$3.50
Sale price
$3.50
Regular price
Let customers speak for us
Not too sweet and yet tasty and flavourful! I wish they’re available at a bake shop
JAR
It was great! Not too sweet and tasty!
JAR
Classic and delicious! These pecan tarts are yummy!
Anonymous
I first tried these in October 2025 - I was automatically hooked. Perfect amout of peanut butter, the chocolate pastry is soo good. These are my favourite!
Anonymous
Great Variety. The mini chocolate tarts and sweet potato are to die for! Perfect little bite sizes.
Anonymous
I have ordered from Surgar 2 Quared many times. Each time I received delicious butter tarts. The pastry is perfection and I enjoy many of the different flavours. I order specific mini tarts for my mom's birthday and they accommodated my request no problem. Thank you so much
Anonymous
Soo good! Fudge on top was yummy
Anonymous
